For a gas water heater, check that the gas control is on and look for the pilot or an error light; for electric, check the breaker. If you smell gas, leave and call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504. If the heater is done, Fixr's national average range for a tank-style replacement is $1,000 to $2,700, and North Carolina's permit rules depend on what changes.

Key facts
- Gas heater checks
- Gas control setting, pilot or status light
- Electric heater checks
- Breaker; reset button behind the upper panel (power off first)
- Gas smell
- Get far away, then 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas, 800.752.7504
- Tank-style replacement
- $1,000–$2,700 (Fixr, national average range)
- Permit
- Exempt like-for-like only under G.S. 160D-1110(a)(2) conditions
- Heat pump water heater rebate
- Up to $1,750, income-qualified
- Licensing
- NC State Board of Examiners of Plumbing, Heating & Fire Sprinkler Contractors
Gas or electric? Follow your branch
Gas water heater
- Any gas smell? Don't touch the heater. Get far away from the smell, then call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504. Piedmont's guidance is not to operate valves or use anything that could spark.
- Gas control. Make sure the knob is set to on, not pilot or vacation.
- Pilot or status light. Older units have a visible pilot; newer ones have a status light that blinks a code. Note it. Relight only by the instructions on the label, and only if there's no smell of gas.
- Is gas reaching the house? If the stove or furnace won't light either, the problem may be the supply, not the heater.
Electric water heater
- Breaker. Check for a tripped double breaker. Reset once. If it trips again, leave it off and call.
- High-limit reset. With the breaker off, the upper access panel usually hides a red reset button. A heater that keeps tripping it has a fault worth a plumber's visit.
Want a price for your home? Call a local plumber for a written quote.
Phone line opening soonSigns the heater itself has failed
- Water on the floor around the base (see water heater leaking).
- Rusty hot water, or rumbling and popping as it heats.
- Hot water that runs out much faster than it used to.
Replacing it in Charlotte
Fixr's national average range for a tank-style heater is $1,000 to $2,700. Under G.S. 160D-1110, no permit is needed for connecting a replacement only in a one- or two-family dwelling, when the installer is licensed under G.S. 87-21, personally examines the work at completion and ensures a leak test of the gas piping, when the replacement meets the current NC State Building Code, and when the fuel, energy source, location and capacity stay the same, with no change in the routing or sizing of venting and piping and no greater input. Anything else means a permit from Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement.
A heat pump water heater qualifies for up to $1,750 from Energy Saver North Carolina for income-qualified households; see rebates. Plumbers are licensed by the NC State Board of Examiners of Plumbing, Heating & Fire Sprinkler Contractors.
What a repair usually costs
National ranges from cost publishers, not Charlotte quotes. The fault decides the price, so ask for it in writing before work starts.
| Job | National range | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater repair | $150 to $750 | Fixr, updated Aug 2025 |
When you call: 4 questions to ask
- Does this water heater swap meet every condition of the North Carolina permit exemption, or will you pull a permit?
- Are you licensed under G.S. 87-21, and will you personally examine the finished work and leak test the gas piping?
- Is the problem on my side of the Charlotte Water meter or theirs?
- Is the service-call fee credited if I go ahead?
A fair written quote shows the heater or parts, labor, any permit, haul-away, and the written warranty. Check any contractor's license on the NC plumbing, heating and fire sprinkler board's license search before work starts.
What happens when you call
- You're connectedStraight to a local plumber that serves your area and takes calls like yours.
- You get a priceDescribe the problem, ask for a written quote and their license number. No obligation.
Common questions
Why do I have no hot water but the heater is on?
On gas units, the pilot or igniter may have failed; on electric units, an element or the high-limit switch. Check the basics first, then call.
Is it safe to relight the pilot?
Only by the instructions on the label, and never if you smell gas. If you do, leave and call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504.
What does a new water heater cost?
Fixr's national average range for a tank-style unit is $1,000 to $2,700.
Do I need a permit to replace it?
Only if the job falls outside North Carolina's exemption, for example a change of fuel, location or size, or an installer who isn't licensed under G.S. 87-21.
Related guides
Sources
- Piedmont Natural Gas: Safety information
- Piedmont Natural Gas: Natural gas safety
- Fixr: Gas water heater cost
- North Carolina General Statute 160D-1110: Building permits
- Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement: Permitting
- NC Department of Environmental Quality: Energy Saver North Carolina available in all 100 counties (February 10, 2026)
- NC State Board of Examiners of Plumbing, Heating & Fire Sprinkler Contractors: Consumer awareness
Costs are typical ranges. Your quote depends on your home. Rules and rebates change; check the original source before you rely on a figure. Something wrong? Tell us via the contact on the Impressum page.