A roofer or adjuster says hail damage means the roof needs replacing, usually paid by insurance. Roof replacement in Colorado averages about $9,534 and can range from $7,332 to $23,862 (This Old House, June 2026). With insurance paying, the numbers to check are the adjuster's scope and your share.
Key facts
- Benchmark price
- $7,332–$23,862
- Get this first
- Compare the adjuster's estimate with the roofer's contract line by line: squares, layers, drip edge, vents, ice and water shield, permit.
- Line item to watch
- Class 4 impact-resistant shingles
Most of a hail roof quote is decided before the roofer names a price. The adjuster's estimate sets what insurance pays, and the contract sets what you actually get.
Your job is to make those two documents match, and to know which lines are yours to pay.
Contract vs estimate: the checks
- Compare the adjuster's estimate with the roofer's contract line by line: squares, layers, drip edge, vents, ice and water shield, permit.
- Colorado law requires a written contract with scope, cost and dates, and gives you 72 hours to cancel (and 72 hours after an insurance denial).
- A roofer may not pay, waive or rebate your deductible. An offer to do so is a red flag.
- Offers to cover your deductible.
- Pressure to sign the same day, or a contract without scope, cost and dates.
Compare the contract total
Typical range: $7,332–$23,862.
The price and your share
Roof replacement in Colorado averages about $9,534 and can range from $7,332 to $23,862 (This Old House, June 2026). After a covered hail claim, you normally pay your deductible and any upgrades you choose.
Upgrades and supplements
| Item | Fine when | Get it explained when |
|---|---|---|
| Class 4 impact-resistant shingles | You'll stay in the house; many insurers give a discount and they resist hail better. | It's presented as covered by insurance when it isn't, or the price difference isn't written down. |
| Gutters, siding or window upgrades | They're damaged and on the adjuster's scope, or you want them. | They're added to the contract without being on the claim and without a separate price. |
| A 'supplement' you weren't told about | Legitimate supplements add items the adjuster missed, with photos. | You can't see what was added or why. |
Ask the roofer, in writing
- Can I see the contract next to the adjuster's estimate?
- What exactly will I pay out of pocket?
- What's your PPRBD license number?
Want a second hail inspection before you sign? Call another local roofer.
Phone line opening soonWhen you call: 4 questions to ask
- What's your PPRBD roofing license number, and can I see proof of insurance?
- Will the contract list scope, cost and start and finish dates, as Colorado law requires?
- Will you tear off all old layers, and what do you charge per sheet of rotten decking?
- Which shingle are you quoting, and is it Class 4?
A fair written quote shows a written contract with scope, cost and dates, your 72-hour right to cancel, and no offer to cover your deductible. Check any contractor's license on pprbd.org before work starts.
What happens when you call
- You're connectedStraight to a local roofer that serves your area and takes calls like yours.
- You get a priceDescribe the problem, ask for a written quote and their license number. No obligation.
Common questions
What do I pay on a hail roof replacement?
Usually your deductible, plus any upgrades you choose that insurance doesn't cover. On actual-cash-value policies you may also pay the depreciation.
Can a roofer pay my deductible in Colorado?
No. Colorado law prohibits roofers from paying, waiving or rebating your insurance deductible.
Related guides
Sources
- This Old House: Roof replacement cost in Colorado (June 2026)
- C.R.S. 6-22-103: Contracts for roofing services: required terms
- Robinson & Henry: Colorado roofing contracts and the deductible rule (C.R.S. 6-22-103 to -105)
- PPRBD: Reroofing guidelines
Costs are typical ranges. Your quote depends on your home. Rules and rebates change; check the original source before you rely on a figure. Something wrong? Tell us via the contact on the Impressum page.