A technician says the metal wall between the flame and your home's air has cracked, which can let carbon monoxide in. Replacing a heat exchanger costs about $1,000–$3,000 when it isn't under warranty and roughly $350–$850 when the part is covered. Ask how the crack was confirmed before choosing a repair or a new furnace.
Key facts
- Fair range
- $1,000–$3,000
- Ask to see
- Ask how it was confirmed.
- Extra most worth questioning
- A full furnace replacement
A crack in the wall between the flame and your home's air can let carbon monoxide in. That makes this a real safety call: a red-tagged furnace stays off, and your carbon monoxide alarms should be working.
It is also the diagnosis most worth a second opinion, because it often comes with a quote for a whole new furnace. Keeping the furnace off and taking a day to compare quotes go together fine.
Three tests that confirm a crack
- Ask how it was confirmed. A solid diagnosis combines a visual inspection, watching the burner flame when the blower starts, and a combustion analysis that measures carbon monoxide.
- Ask for a photo or video of the crack. A camera view alone, with no other test, is thinner evidence.
- Check the warranty. Many heat exchangers carry long or lifetime manufacturer warranties, which can bring the cost down to labor.
- No combustion analysis or photo, just a verbal diagnosis.
- A 'discount if you sign today' on a furnace replacement.
Where your heat exchanger quote sits
Typical range: $1,000–$3,000.
Note: This range is for replacing the heat exchanger. If your quote is for a whole new furnace, compare it with furnace replacement instead: Fixr lists about $3,800–$10,000 nationally for a natural gas furnace, and a Colorado Springs guide (HVAC Project Cost) puts local HVAC replacements 10–20% above national averages. More
Heat exchanger or whole furnace
Replacing a heat exchanger costs about $1,000–$3,000 when it isn't under warranty and roughly $350–$850 when the part is covered. Many people replace the whole furnace instead, especially if it's 15+ years old.
What gets bundled with a crack diagnosis
| Bundled item | Reasonable when | Ask why when |
|---|---|---|
| A full furnace replacement | The crack is confirmed and the furnace is older or out of warranty. | The furnace is young and the heat exchanger is still under warranty. |
| A new AC at the same time | The AC is old, inefficient or failing, and pairing saves on labor. | It's presented as required with a furnace replacement. It isn't. |
| Same-day decision pricing | Never needed. A safety issue means turning the furnace off. You can still take a day to compare quotes. | There's pressure to sign before you can get a second opinion. |
Want a combustion test from a different heating company before you decide? Call a local pro.
Phone line opening soonQuestions for the technician who found it
- How did you confirm the crack: visual, flame test, combustion analysis?
- Can I have the photo or video?
- Is the heat exchanger still under the manufacturer's warranty?
When you call: 4 questions to ask
- Is the diagnostic or trip fee credited toward the repair?
- Will you size a new system with a load calculation and set it up for our altitude?
- Is the PPRBD mechanical permit included, and what's your PPRBD license number?
- Does this model qualify for the Colorado Springs Utilities rebate, and who files it?
A fair written quote shows model numbers and efficiency, altitude setup, the permit and inspection, removal of the old unit, and parts and labor warranty. Check any contractor's license on pprbd.org before work starts.
What happens when you call
- You're connectedStraight to a local heating & cooling pro that serves your area and takes calls like yours.
- You get a priceDescribe the problem, ask for a written quote and their license number. No obligation.
Common questions
Should I keep running a furnace with a cracked heat exchanger?
No. If a technician red-tags it, keep it off, use space heaters safely and make sure you have working carbon monoxide alarms. You can still get a second opinion before deciding on repair or replacement.
Is a cracked heat exchanger diagnosis ever a scam?
Cracks are real and dangerous, but the diagnosis is also a common route to a big sale. Ask how it was confirmed and for the photo. A second inspection with a combustion analyzer is worth the cost.
Related guides
Sources
- HomeGuide: Heat exchanger replacement cost
- AC Direct: Cracked heat exchanger: what a legitimate diagnosis includes
- Fixr: How much does a new furnace cost? (2026 data)
- HVAC Project Cost: Colorado Springs HVAC replacement cost (2026 guide)
- Trane: Repair or replace: the $5,000 rule
Costs are typical ranges. Your quote depends on your home. Rules and rebates change; check the original source before you rely on a figure. Something wrong? Tell us via the contact on the Impressum page.