The fix depends on the fuel. On gas, look at the pilot or igniter and whether other gas appliances still work; on electric, look at the breaker before anything else. Smell gas at any point and the plan changes: go outside, then call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504. Inside City of Greenville limits, a water heater isn't on the City's exception list, so plan on a permit; confirm with 864-467-4505.

Key facts
- Gas heater
- Check pilot or ignition, gas valve, other gas appliances
- Electric heater
- Check the breaker; elements and thermostats are for a pro
- Gas smell
- Leave; 911 and Piedmont, 800.752.7504
- Power out?
- Duke Energy, 800.POWERON (800.769.3766)
- Replacement permit
- Not on the City's exception list; plan on one (864-467-4505)
- Tank-style gas heater
- $1,000–$2,700 (national average range, Fixr)
- License
- RBP, SC LLR Residential Builders Commission
Gas heater
- Look at the pilot or ignition. Older tanks have a visible pilot flame; newer ones light electronically. Follow the lighting instructions on the tank's label exactly, or leave it to a plumber.
- Is the gas on? If the stove or furnace isn't working either, the problem may be supply rather than the heater.
- Smell gas? Don't try to light anything. Get well away, then call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504.
Electric heater
- The double breaker. Electric tanks usually sit on a two-pole breaker. One reset is fine; a second trip means leave it off and get help.
- Lights out next door too? Then Duke Energy needs to hear about it: 800.POWERON (800.769.3766).
- Elements and thermostats sit behind panels carrying full voltage. Leave those to an electrician or plumber.
Only a little hot water?
Hot water that runs out quickly can mean a failed element in an electric unit, sediment in the tank, or simply a tank too small for the household. A plumber can tell which.
Want a price for your home? Call a local plumber for a written quote.
Phone line opening soonIf it's the end of the line
If the plumber says the tank is done, a new one inside the City of Greenville isn't on the City's exception list, so plan on a permit; confirm with 864-467-4505. The City's plumbing exceptions cover leak repairs, clearing stoppages and reinstalling toilets. Fixr's national average range for a tank-style gas water heater is $1,000 to $2,700. Ask for the RBP license number and check it on the licensee lookup.
What a repair usually costs
National ranges from cost publishers, not Greenville quotes. The fault decides the price, so ask for it in writing before work starts.
| Job | National range | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater repair | $150 to $750 | Fixr, updated Aug 2025 |
When you call: 4 questions to ask
- Will you pull the City permit for the new water heater, including after an emergency swap?
- Is the leak on my side of the Greenville Water meter setter, or the utility's?
- What's your Residential Specialty Plumbing (RBP) license number?
- Does the service-call fee count toward the repair?
A fair written quote shows the heater or parts, labor, the permit, haul-away of the old tank and the written warranty. Check any contractor's license on the SC LLR Residential Builders Commission licensee lookup before work starts.
What happens when you call
- You're connectedStraight to a local plumber that serves your area and takes calls like yours.
- You get a priceDescribe the problem, ask for a written quote and their license number. No obligation.
Common questions
The taps run cold. Where do I start?
Gas heater: the pilot or igniter, and whether other gas appliances work. Electric heater: the breaker, then a technician for the elements.
Can I relight the pilot myself?
Only by the lighting instructions printed on the tank, and never with a gas smell in the air. With a gas smell, get outside and call 911 and Piedmont Natural Gas at 800.752.7504.
Will a replacement heater need a City permit?
Inside Greenville city limits, a water heater isn't on the City's exception list, so plan on a permit; confirm with 864-467-4505.
What's the budget for a new tank?
Fixr's national average range for a tank-style gas water heater is $1,000 to $2,700.
Related guides
Sources
- Piedmont Natural Gas: Natural gas safety
- Duke Energy news release, March 15, 2026: preparing for damaging high winds across the Carolinas
- City of Greenville: Do You Need A Permit?
- Fixr: Gas water heater cost
- SC LLR Residential Builders Commission: Licensure
- SC LLR Residential Builders Commission: Licensee Lookup
Costs are typical ranges. Your quote depends on your home. Rules and rebates change; check the original source before you rely on a figure. Something wrong? Tell us via the contact on the Impressum page.